2. digital
  3. 1394226042

PS Audio DAC II or Bryston: two great machines

I have decided that it's time to move up from my Rega DAC, and I am considering the above two machines. I know, I know, the solution is to listen to them myself and decide on my taste, but I don't have the option to do that. Both DACs have received rave reviews, though the retail price of the PS Audio is (was) almost twice that of the new Bryston BDA-2. The PS Audio II is now being replaced by the DirectStream, so there are many good deals on the discontinued II.

Anyone have any thoughts on how these compare? Both are described as being supremely musical. Can one argue that the PS Audio is twice as musical, given that it is (was) twice as expensive? :)

My amp is a Cary integrated. I have heard Bryston gear only once or twice in the past. To the extent that Bryston may have a house sound, my gut tells me that the Bryston DAC would not be a good match with Cary. In another thread, a person described the PS Audio as somewhat akin to the Cary 300B. On the one hand that is encouraging, on the other hand it may mean too much Cary.

Any thoughts? I'm also considering the new McIntosh D100. That looks sweet.
rfprice
nglazer
846 posts
 
Have not heard the Bryston DAC ( have the BDP-1, which is a terrific product with fantastic support) but have the PWD MkII (now superseded by a new PS Audio DSD - capable DAC). It is an excellent product. I have had a number of CDP's and DAC's over the years and this is by far the finest, most versatile and dependable sounding DAC (meaning it does nothing wrong) I have had. Used price now will be dropping, making it even more of a bargain. Plus, it is beautiful to look at.

Neal
rockyboy
335 posts
 
I'm extremely happy with the detail and musicality of my Bryston BPA-1/BDA-1 combo. Can't address compatibility question.
rfprice OP
150 posts
 
Neal, are you saying that you swapped the MkII for the DSD? If so, how do you like the DSD?
goldprintaudio's avatar
Ag insider logo xs@2x
goldprintaudio
502 posts
 
Just curious, but since you have a Cary integrated now, have you considered either of the new Cary DACs? They are very, very good.

***Cary dealer disclaimer***
lwin's avatar
lwin
570 posts
 
I have CARY gear and I tried the BDA 1 & I liked it but the PS Audio MK I was better & the Mk II is quite a bit better. I did not try the BDA II because it was not available at the time but I don't think you can go wrong with either DAC. The PS Audio MKII as another participant said is being replaced & I have seen the MKII deeply discounted for new let alone used units. You will probably find the pricing very close for either the PS Audio or the Bryston.
More to discover