CD vs. SACD vs. DVD-Audio vs Vinyl vs...


Which format do you like the most, or find to be the closest to the original master tapes? Or, if you attend live concerts (or play and instrument), which format do you prefer and why?
wenterprisesnw
Hi Garfish, Carl, sorry if I can't act on every suggestion but I do value your opinion and am impressed with your experience with so many products. I am most interested in The Harmonic Tech. coax. I am also curious about the Truthlink. I need something that leans toward forgiving. Garfish, there seems to be conflicting opinions regarding Vibrapods, I would most likely want to try something under my DVD player first, CD player second. Carl, Are AQ little feet expensive?
Hi Bmp; I've read literally dozens of positive reviews or comments on Vibrapods, and you'll note that Redkiwi (above) admitted they were "good" under some components. He did not like them under "his" speakers. I did see a magazine review where the reviewer put them under his large speakers to good effect (as I have carpet, I have not tried them under my big 3A speakers). I've not tried Audioquest Little feet (they also make big feet), but I think they work on a similar principle to Vibrapods, and I wouldn't hesitate to use them. They have been well reviwed. I also like Vibrapods because they are relatively flat and don't take up much space under a component. They come in five different weight bearing capacities, so you have to use the ones that best match the weitht of you components. At $24. bucks for a set of four, if you don't like them under your equipment, you could put them under a potted plant and smile:) Happy listening.
The AQ little and big feet were made with Sorbothane (a Dupont invention, I think). Now they're made with a gel that might be related to Sorbothane. I've not heard those latest ones. The little feet made an incredible improvement between many different monitor speakers, and sand-filled stands (especially on suspended wood floors). I don't use them under my other components, because there wasn't significant improvement. I attribute this to their higher mass, and being less affected by vibration. The HT Truthlink would definitely be better suited than the Silway. If you want something even cheaper, try the Straightwire Encore. It's as neutral as any interconnect, just not as hi'rez or low in distortion as the more expensive ones. It worked perfectly with my Panasonic DVD player. DOES ANYBODY LIKE THE ORIGINAL BEDINI CLARIFIER??? I'm trying one right now...
Hi Garfish. Perhaps I should elaborate concerning Vibrapods, to see if we still disagree. In the context of their price they are very good. But in the context of a system that costs more than $15k, I would strongly recommend trying Townshend CD Sinks instead - at a cost of around $200 each (I am guessing a bit as to price because I do not live in the US) - under light weight components. As it happens I do not like the effect of the bigger and more expensive Seismic Sink products (I own some but they gather dust in the cupboard). I tried Vibrapods under my tube monoblocks but found there was a very odd resonance effect in the middle of the midrange that was intrusive - hence my preference for an inner tube - a Sink product not being practical in this application. Like all vibration products, there is the potential for vibration interactions that are very different from component to component. When I first tried Vibrapods under my speakers (both Thiels and Martin Logan) I was very impressed at the improvement in soundstage and the reduction in cabinet resonance. But it took me about a week to realise that I was getting a lot less enjoyment from well recorded vocalists. For some reason there was a problem with articulation and coherence in the midrange with the Vibrapods in place. As soon as I took them out, the thrill of listening to a great singer returned. I can very well imagine that someone with different musical tastes would not notice the problem that I found. As a result of all this I have come to the general conclusion that without some form of compliance in your vibration control system, you get some nasty and intrusive narrow band resonances that often make the sound unmusically forward and which collapses the soundstage. When you introduce something compliant such as Vibrapods, Sorbathane, various polymer footers, various bladder or sprung products, you move the resonances down in frequency and they occupy a broader band. The effect is generally an improvement as it can take away what was previously an irritating edge to the sound. But having played with as many of these as I could get my hands on, I concluded that the CD sink managed to not only remove the edge, but retain dynamics, leading edge definition and coherence. Many of the others remove the edge, but at the expense of one of the other characteristics I just listed. Vibrapods are better than having only the rubber feet on your components as the "compliance" I refer to - except perhaps in the case of some (but not all) Sonic Frontiers products which use very good polymer feet (there are probably others too). I also prefer Vibrapods to Sorbothane (I have not tried the Gel version yet). But if you get just the right bladder product, the result is very much better in a top flight system IMHO.