Pbb, I am sincerely happy you are enjoying both LP and CD. You have more choices than ever and an opportunity to have fun and learn from your efforts.
If you resolve your (valid) complaints with your turntable playback noise, you may become satisfied with analog.
I hope you believe me when I say this. My turntable is totally silent, no noise, no pops and no ticks. This on almost 100% of my records. Certainly there are some records that are noisy to the point of being un- listenable. Some have one tick on side A or B, and I allow that in order to enjoy the other 45 minutes of bliss.
I would estimate that out of my (approx.) 6000 LPs, there are only a few with enough defect to keep me from enjoying the sound. Some of my records were bought in the mid 1960s when I was a kid. In spite of their age, a through cleaning and they are for the most part, noise free.
Turntable and tonearm quality, brand and set up of the cartridge, and quality of the phono stage all play a role in the end results. Cleaning any debris from (even new) LPs is necessary to obtain the silence I describe.
Maybe this is worth the effort to you and maybe not. At least youre making an effort, enjoying the music and experimenting, and for that, I admire you.