I recall the Sonus cartridges were mid-priced moving magnets from the 80s. Suspension hardening generally occurs over the long term (years) not short term (hours) so I'm not sure what is causing your observations. Also, suspension problems seem to be more of an issue with moving coils than moving magnets (maybe because no-body keeps their moving magnet stylii long enough for them to harden). Sounds like dirt on the stylus but this should be heard as audible distortion. I guess you could try the Stylast treatment on your cheapest cartridge. If that works, what-the-heck, dunk them all in it!
keith
keith