Best way of removing rust from silver or other

Agree with Ed. Did a quick search on the internet and turned this up:

CuO (copper oxide) has a magnetic susceptibility of +267 while AgO (silver oxide) has a magnetic susceptibility of -19. 

By way of comparison, the magnetic susceptibility of FeO (ferric oxide, (rust) is 293.  

The much higher magnetic susceptibility of CuO means the skin depth will be *very* thin, and net skin resistivity very high.  Meanwhile, the negative value for AgO means that the skin depth will be greater than anticipated.

As with steel versus copper we have to look beyond DC resistance to find out which material is better suited.  It turns out that oxidized copper is almost as bad as oxidized steel That is why silver plating is often suggested for conductors.  

Although the conductivity of silver is only 6% better than copper, when each surface is compared in an oxidized state, silver is a far superior conductor than copper.

Short answer, if you like the sound of copper, keep it free of oxidation. My own suggestion to polish and renew either material is Flitz polish from Germany. The best Flitz is called Polier and second best is Flitz metal polish.

Be careful, most polishes contain abrasive cutters and they certainly do the job. Household furniture polish might be the only exception. For soft metals, i.e. copper, aluminum, silver, and gold use a cleaner like Meguiar's Cleaner/Wax. It's automotive clearcoat safe so won't abrade surfaces like anything labeled polish. Run screaming from grandma's favorite pink silver polish as it's loaded with grit.

For hard metals, 0000 steel wool is a safe bet on the likes of pitting chrome (amp chassis) or specially hardened aluminum alloys (bike chainrings).

You can use an eraser to rub off the oxidation. It is cheap, safe, and leaves no chemical. You should use the one for removing ink from ballpoint pen, not the one for removing pencil marks.