Using subs as speaker stands ?


I own the tyler ref monitors, I am thinking of buying 2 tyler taylo base moduals, I am cramped for space,would it work if I placed the monitors directly on ths subs using rubber isolation pads between the monitor and the sub, has anyone tried this ? thanks all
128x128samski
As stated, good stands are going to work better than stacking on the subs. But if you want to try it, look into a product called Microsorb, sold by percyaudio.com. It is a sticky acrylic damping sheet that will not only hold the speakers very effectively, but will also absorb a lot of excess cabinet vibrations.
You might want to think about the Ref II. It is basically the monitor with its own passive subwoofer section. This will give a better appearence. I am sure Ty could make you a bass module for the ref monitor (Lynbrook style). I am not a big fan of powered subs when used with high quality monitors. Getting them to sound just right is time consuming and frustrating. It might be the cheap crossovers they use in the sub amps. Some of my taste in music contains a lot of bass. For me passive is the only way to go.
If you are in a rather small space, you probably don't need two subs anyway. Get one and some good stands for your monitors. Place the sub somewhere in between the monitors for optimium soundstaging.
thanks for all responses, but the responses leed to another question, since some replies sugest that putting monitor on top of subs causes distortion in the sound waves,what about the aerial 10 t where the top modual sits directly on the base modual, also the tyler reference speaker does the same thing and I am sure there are others, if its true that sitting the top peice directly on top the sub section causes distorted sound waves, how do the above mentioned speakers overcome it, thanks all
Without doing the in-depth research on the specific models you mention, the bass units I've usually seen attached to the midrange/tweeter sections are 1) not independently powered (i.e., they are passive units) and 2) specially designed and braced to accommodate the match-up. One unit I have heard that had a powered sub-woofer in the same cabinet as the midrange/tweeter was the Definitive Technology speaker and it was overkill on the low end and dipping rather dramatically in the lower midrange/upper bass region. Was that a design problem? Don't know. I've heard many good things about similarly designed Infinity systems.

Place your hand on top of a sub-woofer and you can feel the vibrations. Place your hand on the cabinet of a speaker cabinet and you would not normally feel the vibrations. There are different design parameters that need to be used under the different design objectives. Stand-alone subwoofers are not designed to be physically connected to other speakers. If they were, they would likely require more space and more bracing in order to reduce the cabinet vibrations.

That's my top-of-mind response. I welcome corrections and expansions of the explanation. Good question. To expand on the question, are there speaker companies that attempt to physically isolate all of the independent speaker units? My experience has been that isolation and stability helps greatly (e.g., speaker cones or stands). I wonder if any company took it further?