2. speakers
  3. 1057178315

Merlin TSM vs the other top monitors

Hello all - I am looking to downsize my speakers (currently have Thiel 2.3) due to space limitations in my NYC apt. ($2200 a month in rent doesn't go too far in manhattan!!!)

I am looking into several of the top monitors including dynaudio special 25, b&w sig 805, jm labs mini and micro utopia...all are generally well reviewed on here (i've already read most of the archived posts)...but i keep hearing great things about the Merlin's, and would also love to help out the little guy instead of throwning more $ towards a giant company (the populist in me), though sound quality will be the determining factor.

my current system consists of:

plinius sa 100
CJ premier 17 pre amp
cary 303 CD player

room is approx 15x9

while i've liked the thiels, they are too big for the room and i'm also looking for a speaker that is a little more musical and engaging

thanks for your thoughts
ericd74
khokugo
122 posts
 
I live in NYC, and I feel your agony. I ended up, and will keep as long as I am here, Sonus Faber Signum. The sound is gorgeous. In my room size, I firmly believe that I can't do better. Since this model has been discontinued (to make room for Cremona line, I heard), from time to time (in fact right now!) there is a good deal on here. This is a gem. Grab it while you can.
BUT, it depends on your taste on music. If you are mostly classical, chamber, or other acoustic music lover, you won't regret.
acuujim
207 posts
 
I have owned the TSM and the Talon Khites and other
All were bested by the Reference 3A MM deCapo's IMO
theaudiotweak
2,796 posts
 
Heard the prototype Harmonic Precision Caravelle's about three months ago. They are the most dynamically coherent speakers I have ever auditioned. Sent a deposit a week ago. Waiting for the grand finale..Tom
chams_uk
159 posts
 
I like several suggestions, and will add my own. So far, the TSM's and Reference 3A De Capo's would be top choices. A couple others to consider are the Totem's, either the 1's or the Mani-2's; or the JM Reynaud Twin Mk 3's (I own these). VERY musical.

My 2 cents. Much luck on your choice.

Todd - chams_uk
finao1
15 posts
 
I don't think you're getting any bad suggestions. I have a small 12x12x9 foot room and have done some experimenting. I have found that my small room does very well with a sealed speaker. Looking at your current choices, I think this would point more to the direction of the Merlin TSM as it is a sealed speaker designed in a true monitor philosophy. I am using the Harbeth HL-P3ES-2 driven by the Levinson 383. The Harbeth is the evolution of the traditional sealed monitor; it may be a consideration and match well with your Plinius.

PS... Don't forget good stands.
Have fun!
More to discover