Hello Nate. Yes, the smartest thing to do is call Kharma for their professional advice.
However, since you asked, I have a little story for you. Awhile back, I was in a professional music store where they sell band and recording studio equipment. I had a passing interest in a beat up pair of Yamaha NS40 studio monitors. The salesman wanted 50% off retail price and I was only willing to pay 75% off retail considering the cabinets were terribly abused and (3) of the woofer dust caps (made of white paper) were pooched in.
The salesman said the (3) pooched in dust caps were not a problem...and I said yeah, right. Sure enough, the salesman had a technician repair all (3) of them in less than (10) minutes right before my eyes.
The tech carefully hand twisted a 1/16" drill bit into each dust cap. He then straightened out a paper clip, curled the tip of the paper clip slightly with needle nosed pliers, carefully inserted the curled tip of the paper clip into each of the 1/16" predrilled holes, and in just a few short minutes the tech had the dust caps looking like new. The tech finished the job nearly to perfection with (3) small dots of Elmer's white glue.
I then had to eat my words about the pooched in dust caps. Still yet, I had to pass on the 50% off retail before the guy started refinishing the beat up cabinets.
Nate, I hope this helps. I like Elevick's idea above of gluing on new caps if my idea does not work out for you.
Regards,
Dan