I have found that sealed box subs seem to be tighter and quicker that ported subs. Ported subs give you more "grunt" for HT by moving more air. I think all the subs on your list are ported.
That said I can give a recommendation to the Dayton Titanic 10" sub from Parts Express. I picked one up on eBay new for $240. I run it in a second system with Omega TS-2 single driver speakers.
It is not a thing of beauty with its black pebble finish but the small sealed box makes it quick and tuneful. No slop, no boom, no overhanging resonance to muddy things up. Adjustable phase and a wide range in crossover point make it easy to integrate. I think that 35 hZ is about the bottom for it but unless you are listening to pipe organ or Rick James you don't miss that last octave.
here is a review:
http://www.audioxpress.com/reviews/media/902ketler1924.pdf
I think that trying to get by cheap will end up being a compromise in the quality of the bass. Only your ears can be the final arbiter.
That said I can give a recommendation to the Dayton Titanic 10" sub from Parts Express. I picked one up on eBay new for $240. I run it in a second system with Omega TS-2 single driver speakers.
It is not a thing of beauty with its black pebble finish but the small sealed box makes it quick and tuneful. No slop, no boom, no overhanging resonance to muddy things up. Adjustable phase and a wide range in crossover point make it easy to integrate. I think that 35 hZ is about the bottom for it but unless you are listening to pipe organ or Rick James you don't miss that last octave.
here is a review:
http://www.audioxpress.com/reviews/media/902ketler1924.pdf
I think that trying to get by cheap will end up being a compromise in the quality of the bass. Only your ears can be the final arbiter.