I'll throw in my perspective, (for what it's worth). I was an ARC dealer for many years and an AI dealer for a few years.
I have personally owned an AI 2C, 2D, 3 and 3A. I have owned almost every preamp that ARC made back in the day.
I would take the SP-11 or SP-15 any day over the AI 3A. This is just a personal preference.
Since we are taking used here, the price difference is pretty large. The ARC SP-11/15 are still going for around $3000 and I've seen AI 3As for around $1000. So that would have to be a factor.