High output MC

If you really don't need a HOMC, try an Ortofon 2M Red. At $99, it's a killer little cart and since you're going to just be using it as an interim cartridge, you could spend the extra $250 you saved...on vinyl!

BTW: The last thing you should buy is a used cartridge with so-called low mileage,you can do more damage on your vinyl with a worn stylus. Check out the Grado Reference Platinum 1 for $350.00 .The Needle Doctor is a good place to start. They always give 10% off and free shipping if you ask!

Great reco's here, my personal favorites are the Blackbird as John mentions and I am a big fan of anything Ortofon.

Try a Nagoka

I'll second the 2M Red, grest cart period. I also have mounted on separate headshells, in addition to this Ortofon, an 2M Black, Shure V15 IV (with Ed Saunders microridge stylus, amazing), Grado Sonata, Stanton 881S (also with Saunders stylus), Stanton 500E (Saunders too) and Grado M+ mono. I run these on a used-but-great-shape Technics SL1200 mkII and it is amazing the different sonic envelopes afforded by these cartridges. An AT440 mla is on its way and that should round out the stable for now.

But whenever I go back the 2M Red, it still puts a smile on my face and it gets my feet a tappin'.

Also, I feel the Ortofon SH-4 headshells are the best out there for the money.