Pedrillo, I'm sure the Clearaudio is an excellent turntable, but there's something out-of-whack about your question: you shouldn't be looking for "the best" phono preamp in the world for a $1000 turntable, that is, unless you're planning to greatly upgrade it in the near future. In fact, even your $2000 new/used budget seems far too high for that level of gear.
If I were you, I'd be looking more in the $1000/used category, or new if that's your preference. Personally-speaking, my VPI Aries 2 plus arm cost around $4K new, and I mated it with a used BAT VK-P10 for around $1400--that is, less than half the cost of the 'table.
Believe it or not, I swear that I was going to recommend the EAR, until I looked at your post again and realized that you already have it! I would suggest not comparing your components to what you hear at audio salons, which is mated with different equipment and tweaked/modded to the max, often by the designers themselves. With those standards, you'll *never* be satisfied.
So I suggest you stick with the EAR, which is a very fine piece of equipment, and learn to enjoy it on its own terms. I'd guess that you wouldn't get the same sound you heard at the store even with a $7000 phono amp. You know what they say about the grass being greener on the other side? Well, it's just as true of audio.