To make a proper recommendation, I need to know room size, how acoustally dead (absortive) or live (reflective) your listening room is, how loudly & what you usually listen to (chamber music requires less amp power than rock or orchestral music).
That said, I think the problem is likely an imbalance between your preamp's output voltage & amp's input sensitivity based your observation that you "can't turn the pre past 9:00 and keep it under wall shaking decibels."
I would say contacting Bryston and/or Conrad-Johnson about your concern is your best bet.
You may just need an attenuator or passive level control.
That said, I think the problem is likely an imbalance between your preamp's output voltage & amp's input sensitivity based your observation that you "can't turn the pre past 9:00 and keep it under wall shaking decibels."
I would say contacting Bryston and/or Conrad-Johnson about your concern is your best bet.
You may just need an attenuator or passive level control.