hi tvad:
thank you for reminding me to be objective.
my point regarding the difference between solid state and tube amps is that there is a sonic signature which is evident when listening to solid state amps, which makes it possible to identify the amplifier as solid state. the region, 1000 hz to 3000 hz, is the range which disintguishes the sound of many solid state amplifiers from many tube amplifiers.
there are two questions, how to precisely describe the difference and what parameters to measure.
one of the challenges of audio is the correlatation of (subjective) listening experiences with the appropriate quantifiable variables. i can not specify what to measure, only to suggest that the range covering upper midrange and upper treble fundamental frequencies and their harmonics may be worth measuring.
perhaps, i would hypothesize that there are measurable differences between the harmonic envelopes based upon the aforementioned frequency range which can distinguish a tube amp from a solid state amp.
if so , it may be difficult to find a solid state amp that is tube like. of course, what tube amp would be used as the benchmark ?? would it be a design from the 60's through the 1980's or a current production tube amp ?
i am afraid i have raised more questions than have answered them.
i will conclude by saying that the quest for a tube-like solid state amp, requires very spefici facts, which have yet to be mentioned, including, what tube amp sconstitutes the benchmark for "tube-like" quality, or would there be more than one tube amp, since there are differences between tube amps, and what is the criteriaon for "tube-like character " ?
you can blame tvad fror my rambling. thanks again tvad for reminding me of my principles. i sometimes fall into subjectivity--sorry about that.
thank you for reminding me to be objective.
my point regarding the difference between solid state and tube amps is that there is a sonic signature which is evident when listening to solid state amps, which makes it possible to identify the amplifier as solid state. the region, 1000 hz to 3000 hz, is the range which disintguishes the sound of many solid state amplifiers from many tube amplifiers.
there are two questions, how to precisely describe the difference and what parameters to measure.
one of the challenges of audio is the correlatation of (subjective) listening experiences with the appropriate quantifiable variables. i can not specify what to measure, only to suggest that the range covering upper midrange and upper treble fundamental frequencies and their harmonics may be worth measuring.
perhaps, i would hypothesize that there are measurable differences between the harmonic envelopes based upon the aforementioned frequency range which can distinguish a tube amp from a solid state amp.
if so , it may be difficult to find a solid state amp that is tube like. of course, what tube amp would be used as the benchmark ?? would it be a design from the 60's through the 1980's or a current production tube amp ?
i am afraid i have raised more questions than have answered them.
i will conclude by saying that the quest for a tube-like solid state amp, requires very spefici facts, which have yet to be mentioned, including, what tube amp sconstitutes the benchmark for "tube-like" quality, or would there be more than one tube amp, since there are differences between tube amps, and what is the criteriaon for "tube-like character " ?
you can blame tvad fror my rambling. thanks again tvad for reminding me of my principles. i sometimes fall into subjectivity--sorry about that.