05-05-09: Sidssp
The concern of resistor based attenuator is that the output impedance changes
a lot depending on the setting. That means when matched with a low input
impedance amp, your system may sound very different as you turns the volume
up and down.
I'm afraid that I do not quite agree with you. For example, here is one implementation of a resistor attenuator:
http://www.tweakaudio.com/Attenuator%20info.htmlThe only places where the impedance will be high & is likely to affect the sonics is at the -0.5dB, -3dB, -5dB, -7dB settings. Of these settings the -7dB setting is probably the best as the effective impedance the power amp would see in the 500 Ohms region. This is still high for a 10K input impedance power amp but it just *might* work - on the cusp.
(BTW, a digression: my calculations show the 1M resistor provides -0.008dB attenuation, the 4.99K provides -1.5dB attenuation, the 1.69K provides -4dB attenuation, etc. Am I missing something here? Is he adding some other resistor in series w/ the 1K such as the source output impedance (which is not shown)?)
More often than not, the user is going to be in the -31dB range where the effective resistance of this attenuator will be defined by the resistor to ground - which is a very small value. Thus, for even a 10K input impedance power amp this should not be an issue.
(this is all electrically speaking, which is the focus here. No idea what the in-line attenuator does to the overall sonics - my intent is *not* to discuss that here).