My vote - Sansui TU-717. Classic good looks, great stock performance, regular $200-$300 availability, and favorite of many modifiers for even better performance.
FM Tuner Info is a good stop for more information. There are plenty of really good sounding, [relatively] inexpensive tuners out there (McIntosh included) - it's just silly not to have one if you have some decent stations in your area.
Good hunting!