Is upgrading worth it?

Digepix. I know exactly what you are talking back. Its not that you like the sound of you old amp better, it's just more forgiving on lesser recordings. Very common problem. A lot of people make that mistake: they run around with a bunch of audiophile CD's to test and set up the equipment and when they listen to what they really like, they realize a mistake was made. I can give 2 suggestions. 1. Since you still have your old system, keep it and just use it for certain problem recordings. 2. Get an eq. Run a straight cable from your CD player to the preamp and another one from the CD player to the eq. Then take another IC and go from the eq to a different input on your preamp. That way you can switch back and forth.

It's true that a more revealing system will reveal more flaws. But it'll also reveal more strengths in a poor recording too. If all you're focusing on is the flaws, that's all you'll hear.

I bought a system to listen to my music on. I don't buy music to listen to my system. There's a difference.

My system isn't known for being warm, smooth, forgiving, etc. (Bryston B60, Audio Physic Yara Evolution bookshelves, Rega DAC (not as forgiving as people think)). I've also heard my music on $100k systems, and bad recordings are still bad, yet they're still highly enjoyable. My library consists of rock, classic rock, metal, and alternative almost exclusively. With the exception of Pink Floyd and one or two others, none of this stuff would be 'audiophile approved.'

There are very, very few albums I can't listen through my stereo due to sonics. Metallica's Death Magnetic being one. About 3 or 4 tracks into it, the amount of compression rely wears me down. I can't listen to it much further on my iPod either, so it's not like my system is to blame. The only place I can listen to it is in my car.

"I bought a system to listen to my music on. I don't buy music to listen to my system. There's a difference."

Well Said!!

I've never had the money to indulge my whims. Or the inclination to skip other stuff to go with upgrade fever.
So, my system remains stable for long time periods. Before the upgrade I did from 3 to 5 years ago, my system had been stable for about 2 decades. Stuff just wore out. I'd like to get my original 14 bit Magnevox CD player fixed.

I've got a few CDs which simply don't sound right....and in those cases, not even in the car.

I think some with upgrade fever get caught up in trying to hit a moving target.

There are mistakes a lot of people make during upgrades. When you buy something new, and it has a sonic characteristic that is really not liked, pass it on. Everything I bought new or used, if I didn't like it at first, I let it go. When I get something new and like it right out of the box, I know it's a keeper.

A lot of people get caught thinking it will improve with break-in. Then, they start getting accustomed to that sound that they didn't like. I do the opposite. It needs to make me happy right at the beginning. Then, if there are any changes, it seems to be for the better, after it builds up some hours. Result, I'm happy with everything in my system.

If you make a compromise with these new components, and worse yet several of them, that same characteristic you didn't like in the beginning can still be there, maybe not as much of it, but still there. If that happened with a lot of you components, it adds up more, and you probably have a whole system you don't like.

Keep the new items you enjoy out of the box. Then you may be really happy with the end result, especially if most of it turned out better (after hours were put on it) like I am.
I think this mistake is made too often. It takes more trial and error. But, in the end it's worth it, at least for me.