I'm not sure what the problem was with the OP's set up. Again, my Cary's are having no issues with my 3.7R's. They handle Mahler(front row loud)without complaint. There is not an inherent incompatibility between the Cary's and the Maggies. Something else was not right.
As for the OP's preference for the sound of the Pass 250.5, well, there is a reason Pass amps have such a great reputation. I wouldn't mind having a chance to A/B the Pass and Cary's myself.
As for the OP's preference for the sound of the Pass 250.5, well, there is a reason Pass amps have such a great reputation. I wouldn't mind having a chance to A/B the Pass and Cary's myself.