2. speakers
  3. 1360620355

Need speaker advice

One of my Silverline Audio SR-17.5 monitors has developed a serious tweeter problem that might require complete tweeter replacement (tweeter fades out and in unpredictably). I was told the replacement would cost close to $2,000. Since the speakers are about 3-4 yrs old (I bought them used but in pristine condition almost 3 yrs ago), I'm actually considering buying a different pair of speakers for about $2,000 to replace the Silverlines until I can afford something better.

The two speakers I'm strongly considering are the Acoustic Zen Adagio Jr. (I might be able to get them slightly used) or Vandersteen 2CE Sig II. I know there are other excellent monitors for about $2K out there, but I'm afraid they won't provide enough slam for my tastes, like the SR-17.5 can deliver (e.g., GMA Rio, Reference 3A MM De Capo BE, Harbeth P3ESR).

The challenge I'm facing in my selection, however, is the limitations of my listening area, which measures 11x12x9. The room is actually bigger as it is not completely rectangular, but opens on one side to a bathroom and walk-in closet area that's 3x7 sans the actual closet and the bathroom. I treated the room acoustically and the SR-17.5 blend in very nicely. So my question is whether the Vandies or Adagios might be able to blend in as nicely, or are just too much for the space. Other suggestions are also welcome. I have not completely rejected the idea of fixing the Silverlines, but they already had the crossovers replaced (this was the initial diagnosis, but did not fix the problem), and I have reservations about putting another $2,000 into a speaker that's a few years' old.

The rest of my system is an analog front with a ss phono preamp, tube line preamp and tube monoblocks so any replacement must be tube friendly, i.e., stable impedance, preferably higher sensitivity, but my amps can probably handle average sensitivity as well. Neutrality and transparency is the key as well.

My tastes are roughly classic rock (75%) and classic jazz (25%). Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

actusreus
actusreus OP
733 posts
 
Jim,
The speakers were already sent to the manufacturer after the problem began. I never really found out what the actual problem was, but Alan replaced the crossovers, or at least some parts in them, and re-soldered connections. I was informed there was no driver damage. When I got the speakers back, the same problem continued, in the same speaker, and moved with the speaker as I swapped them. My dealer told me the tweeter is expensive and you have to replace both. He didn't give me an exact amount, but said it'd be probably at least $1,600 and possibly $1,800. The speakers cost me $2,700 plus close to $400 for the recent fix, which apparently did not fix the problem so I'm wondering whether it makes sense to continue putting money into it. The shipping alone is close to $200.
wolf_garcia
6,711 posts
 
Alan Yun is a nice dude and I'm sure he would remedy the issue if you allow him...tweeters don't cost anywhere near the price you were quoted so I'd be very suspicious of your "dealer." You can look up some prices of Dynaudio Esotec tweeters in about 16 seconds ($175 a pair maybe?). I suggest removing the tweeters again and sending 'em to Alan as the shipping would be cheap.
actusreus OP
733 posts
 
Yes, Alan is a very nice man, and so is the dealer I bought the speakers from. If he's mistaken, I'm sure it's inadvertent and in good faith.

The tweeter is the Esotec d260; couldn't verify the price. The dealer is coming to my house in a few weeks to check the speaker out, but I'd like to consider other options. The experience has been quite frustrating as the problem seems very unusual - the speaker functions fine for hours at times and then malfunctions immediately at times. I agree it sounds like a bad connection, but I can tell the tweeters were removed when Alan checked the drivers so surely he checked the connections. Also, interestingly, the problem seem to go away when I crank up the volume. For a second I thought perhaps it has something to do with the volume control on my line preamp, but since the problem moved with the speaker and it only affects the tweeter, it can't be it.
m_snow
57 posts
 
Me, I'd buy the tweeter, some good solder and have it myself.

But that's just me.

Aside from that, I'm with pretty much everyone else: I can't see how replacement of ONE tweeter could cost $2k.
actusreus OP
733 posts
 
M_snow,

I'm not very handy with such things as soldering or replacing parts so I'm a bit reluctant to undertake it. Wouldn't want to break something else in the process.

The tweeters come in pairs so you have to buy two. So I'm told.
More to discover