Shadorne
I agree with you:
"You guys are on to something - how to make a grand piano sound real in a room that is not big enough for a grand piano. It seems we all missed the obvious...it just ain't possible. The room is a good 50% of what you hear..."
And my opinion:
A large slice of something good, is still very good...even if it leaves you wanting the whole pie.
30hz or so, while not the whole pie, would still be quite filling.
I know that in my room, listening to piano with one speaker system or the other (-3db@17hz) or (-3db@27hz)...there is not enough bass difference to even bother with.
The only difference between the two speaker systems is sound quality, one system being a large multi-cone type, and the other, a large planer. (I prefer dipole bass for music).
Dave
I agree with you:
"You guys are on to something - how to make a grand piano sound real in a room that is not big enough for a grand piano. It seems we all missed the obvious...it just ain't possible. The room is a good 50% of what you hear..."
And my opinion:
A large slice of something good, is still very good...even if it leaves you wanting the whole pie.
30hz or so, while not the whole pie, would still be quite filling.
I know that in my room, listening to piano with one speaker system or the other (-3db@17hz) or (-3db@27hz)...there is not enough bass difference to even bother with.
The only difference between the two speaker systems is sound quality, one system being a large multi-cone type, and the other, a large planer. (I prefer dipole bass for music).
Dave