"God Bless the Child" on Idol?

After seeing tonights show I think that anyone claiming Jakob has no talent has foreever qualified him/herself as a moronic tonedeaf idiot, that has no business going anywhere near an audio system or live musical performance.

I'm sure our friend schipo sees it differently, but at this point his opinion has about as much credibility as Charlie Sheen's.

Why is it that some people only worship the dead?

I think this year Idol has the best talent in the top 13 that I can remember. I think many of the past finalists would have a hard time making this group. Furthermore, I think that we may see some of the kids that were cut experience success too.

On the women contestants- I actually think they are quite strong.

The performance by Thai was IMO stunning and perfection, her soft voice alone at the start of the song left nothing to hide and it was beautiful. Simon isnt missed, there are IMO 6 seriously talented members of this years cast and its likely to be a fun season.

Edorr: I never said the kid had no talent. Having a big voice doesn't guarantee success. The kid has no idea how to sing the song so when in doubt shoot the works. My opinion is based on listening to quality singing without the hysterical acrobatics thrown in...and to all who think its a bad idea listening to great dead singers? The kids in the hall should learn to listen and turn off the Jennifer Hudson.

You mean Thia Megia?

Yes, that young girl has the voice and demeanor of an angel, both stunning and pitch perfect.

I like Pia Toscano and several others as well.