2. music
  3. 1344827760

Amy Winehouse - Lioness

I must admit that I always dismissed her mostly because of her antics and drug problems, but I after I got this album, I feel quite differently about her. She manages to make even long-standing standards interesting and engaging, and her voice is quite amazing. On some of the songs she sounds strikingly like Ella, and in general exerts an astonishing command of her voice with no effort.

I felt virtually no emotion after her premature demise, aside from the perhaps typical sadness at the news of someone passing so young. However, now I feel we actually lost a great talent that probably never fully bloomed.

If you've been on the fence about Amy Winehouse, get this album; for the low price of under $20 it's a steal. If you're a fan, it's an absolute must.
actusreus
rok2id's avatar
rok2id
7,859 posts
 
"On some of the songs she sounds strikingly like Ella,"

Surely you jest!!

Ella had one of the great voices of all time, regardless of musical genre. And she often dressed like a housewife. Check out several of her cd covers. Esp the ones with Louis. The point is, the more outrageous the personal appearance, the less talent there is.
rnm4
308 posts
 
"the more outrageous the personal appearance, the less talent there is."
Well said, if your aim was silly over-generalization.
actusreus OP
733 posts
 
Rok2id,
No, I don't jest. I said she sounds like Ella on certain songs, not that her voice is as great as Ella's. There is a difference. And honestly, as a huge classic jazz fan, and female jazz singers, I often find myself bored by Ella's signing, and can't take more than a few numbers in succession, as great as Ella was. Guess what, I was not bored listening to this record, from beginning to end. I think your comment about talent is misplaced.
rok2id's avatar
rok2id
7,859 posts
 
The great American soprano, Beverly Sills, said that Ella had the most perfect voice she had ever heard. I defer to Ms Sills' judgement. Whatever you think of Winehouse is valid. I was just shocked at seeing ANYONE compared to Ella. I probaly over reacted. I am flogging myself with a wet noodle as we speak. :)
goofyfoot's avatar
goofyfoot
1,380 posts
 
There is a UK box set of Amy Winehouse that I spotted at FNAC in Belgium and it contains a number of bonus tracks as well as 'Frank' and 'Back in Black'. AS far as making comparisons and I'm not saying that anyone is making comparisons but a gift is a gift, some people will get it more so than others. With regards to her self-destruction, alcohol is the cure for alcoholism and she knew that she was killing herself but the disease kept telling her that she could still drink.
More to discover