When it came to tubing the EL34's in the power supply of my Aesthetix Io and Callisto, I bought the most premium NOS available to insure maximum possible performance. In my Aesthetix this is justified as I have no intention of switching brands and this equipment cost multiple times my investment in these super premium tubes.
If I bought a used Wolcott Presence stereo amp for the bedroom and wanted great sounding tubes, no way would I shell out for original boxed Mullards. Good used tubes beat the stock to death and at a price I can justify.
To clear up any confusion, Wolcott was my reference amp for many years, it is an EXCELLENT design, both in it's stereo and mono block configurations. My comment about super premium tubes in the Io and Callisto are due to the sensitive nature of both high gain preamp and/or moving coil phono stages. Plus, only two tubes are required rather than 16 in the Wolcott.
A bad tube in a Wolcott and one of the bias lights fails to light and you know to switch it. Tube fails in moving coil phono stage and things could get nasty.
In any case, I don't want it to appear that Wolcott is not worthy because I suggested used Mullards would be a smarter buy than new in box variety. My mono blocks required 16 and at $200.00 each for "NOS in new boxes" Mullards I'm out $3200.00. Used that sound as good cost me $800.00.
Leaves more money for other things, same sound quality on both sets of tubes.