I missed that bit in the OP.
Dylan and Paul Simon seem to me odd choices, indeed, for JM to aspire to. IHO, his strength is his playing, which demonstrates real technique and occasional inspiration. His trio - Pino Paladino, in particular - is an impressive blues outfit and, when Mayer hits his stride, they shine. If you want to shoot for the stars, speculate that he'll develop a more consistent, personal guitar sound and perhaps grow into another Larry Carlton (on the one side) or maybe Paul Kossof (on the other). But Dylan or Paul Simon? I don't see that.
Dylan and Paul Simon seem to me odd choices, indeed, for JM to aspire to. IHO, his strength is his playing, which demonstrates real technique and occasional inspiration. His trio - Pino Paladino, in particular - is an impressive blues outfit and, when Mayer hits his stride, they shine. If you want to shoot for the stars, speculate that he'll develop a more consistent, personal guitar sound and perhaps grow into another Larry Carlton (on the one side) or maybe Paul Kossof (on the other). But Dylan or Paul Simon? I don't see that.