Medical Isolation Platforms


Decided to open a discussion on Vibraplane, Halcyonics, Minus-K type tables. What are the merits of active vs passive and industrial vs medical? Is the fuss of setting up compressors and tubing worth the benefits of active and is the only difference with industrial vs medical the mass load? Would a cheap passive platform be an upgrade over say a Symposium or BDR Shelf?
ducatirider

Hi there, thank you for your interest in this topic. I can certainly help you with the first question about merits of active vs passive and industrial vs medical. The benefits of active compression tables is that they have a more gentle compression and are better for patients who need to get up and move around while they're on the table. Industrial tables are stronger than medical tables, but the difference is that they don't have any other features beyond their compressive strength, so it's not worth the fuss.

@sdlevene 1+ 

MinusK platforms are the best available for reasons sdlevene mentioned. Putting any turntable that does not have built in isolation on a MinusK platform will make a significant improvement in performance. This is no idle "tweak."  It is also not cheap costing over $5000. It can be tricky to set up/balance and you have to get use to handling a turntable that can bounce around. They are also not exactly attractive although they do have a relatively new "slim" model. I would recess it into the cabinet. 

If you have an expensive turntable that you really like for whatever reason but, it is not isolated, the MinusK  platform is IMHO mandatory. 

I have a Minus K platform that I use with my turntable.  It does a fantastic job of isolating and is better than most granite/wood/ platforms like HRS/SRA IMO.  It is a bit fidgety initially, but you get used to it just like anything else.  For example, you have to be more careful when you brush the record while it’s rotating on the table or when measuring vtf as the change in weight will bottom out the platform. However, I have not had to adjust the platform due to the different vinyl weights (180/200 gm etc). I did notice and the mfr recommends that optimal results occur when loaded near the rated capacity. I bought the 100 lb rated platform and I think with the additional marble base, the total weight comes close to, but less than 100 lbs.  I think you can go over a few pounds (5 lbs?), but once it exceeds that, it'll no longer work. I also considered a Vibraplane, but having to put in air regularly turned me off. The Stacore had good reviews on WBF, but very expensive. Overall, I'm very happy w my Minus K platform – best bang for the buck. The BM-8 model that I got retails around $3k – the newer low profile platforms are close to $5k. Info at –

https://www.minusk.com/products/bm8-vibration-isolation-platforms-bench-tops-isolators.html

https://www.minusk.com/products/ct2-ultra-thin-low-height-vibration-isolation-platform.html