SEAS Excel Magnesium Midwoofer 51/2 inches ROCK SOLID BASS


Just measured the  edge of surround, it is 5 1/2 inches across.
I am getting TONs or ROCK SOLID BASS.
Does anyone still believe in the woofer theory, bigger is better??

Especially taking room size into acct, Yeah if you havea  palace size room, maybe you want to fill it with bass, soa  8 inch/10 ibch might work for you
I think we should always bring up room size in discussion ofa  ideal speaker bass response.
also note, bass is bass,, well not really, Cone material and how cone is labed makes a  big difference. This SEAS Excel has FREE moving  membrane around the solid copper phase pluf. 
also in considertion is how well doesa  mid woofer/woofer  both voice the upper low fq's to meet  with either a  midrange(which i hate) and a  midtweet. 
I think SEAS hit on the perfect idea of allowing the come to move freely indepent of the solid copper phase plug. 
 Giving a  natural bass response  and adding  the fullest possible bass extention due to its undersized 5.5 cone. 
+ its my guess this magnesiusm material is superior to the old standard paper. 
I know B& W also boasts a  unique cone material, that cool looking yellow fabric,,but i am not at all keen on how their midwoofers voice the upper low fq's. Its too colored for my taste.
So yeah I bought a  sub system to catch the lowest fq's, but as my tech guy says, ,, for what? and suggested that dayton sub amp witha   Cerwin Vega 10 inch,, will only add some dull boominess, with no fidelity (have both for sale on Craiglist cheap) , I always believed maybe I should try to gather the lowest fq's missing in the 5.5 inch midwoofers,,, But really there is not much going on in the 20-30 hz area anyway. 
It would only add this dull  boomy noise.

Somehow Seas Tested and figured out the 5 1/2 inch mid is the best of both worlds,, meets the required low fq register and also meets the Millennium midtweet at a  higher fq  junction making ita  seamless transparent high fidelity image.
At least thats what i am now finally hearing after  upgrading  and repairing my newly acquired Jadis DPL.
IOW the Thors have come alive after all these 18 years when driven with high quality components. 

The Q is,  what is the advantage of havinga  woofer larger than 6/7 (foam edge to foam edge) inches in a speaker design? To what benifit?
Also we should consider how a   specific 6/7 midwoofer voices the upper low fq's that meet the midtweeter. 
This could bea  issue, where the tweet has one particular voice and the widwoifer has a  slightly dif voicing. 
=  will sound like crap.
I think Seas tested all these  critical parimeters and came up with theie Excel line, some 20 years ago,, I am now curious to their new Flagship design the Cresendo + Nextel midwoofer 2 way.
Taking High Fidelity into the 21st century and ,,,beyond.....
I am on the fence should i add this Bifrost as a 2nd speaker,,, or upgrade my Thors xover with all Mundorf Silver caps/ ULTRA resistors/ top of line coils

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqUDP4Byyo4
mozartfan
mozartfan, you can not beat physics. A small cone is not going to project low frequencies well without forcing it which will just increase distortion as the suspension gets to the limits of it's excursion. Big drivers do not have to move as far decreasing distortion. You can beat this problem by using multiple driver arrays which is now common practice but if you want to get really low effortlessly, I mean below 40 Hz down to 18 Hz you need big drivers and heavy enclosures. I get flat down to 18 Hz using 4 12" drivers in separate enclosures each weighing 200 lb, 2000 watts per driver and digital bass management with room control. It will put out 115 dB at 18 Hz. The effect is quite interesting. The whole house rattles, glasses, plates dentures you name it. It feels as if he house is going to jump off it's foundation. Very Cool. 
If you really want to know what your driver is doing you have to measure it. Most companies do this for you and relate it in their specifications. If you build a loudspeaker system you have to measure it at the listening position to determine what it is really doing not in the near field. You can also measure it outside at 5 feet which will give you an idea what the speaker will do in an an-echoic chamber.  You never trust your ears at least initially. 
The benefit of a big driver is that you can go much lower than you can with a smaller driver all other things being equal. Most people have never heard a system that goes below 40 Hz with authority. Their concept of bass is different until they hear a system that really does.
Seas makes excellent drivers and I do believe they make subwoofer drivers.