2. digital
  3. 192742-118562

Sound quality of HD Radio vs CD vs Streamers??

There are a number of Denver area radio stations that broadcast simultaneously in FM and HD.   https://hdradio.com/stations/

I listen to several including KCFR classical music and KUVO jazz/blues. One night in December last year, I heard the beautiful JS Bach keyboard concerto BWV 1052 - Adagio. I listened to the direct HD radio (Sangean HDT-20) output for a bit and then switched to the output of Audio Research DAC 2. I have connected the digital output of HD radio to DAC 2. I was able to make a direct comparison of the two outputs by switching back and forth.

Depth of the sound-stage and separation of the musical instruments were clearly better with DAC2. However, these differences were very small and I attributed those to the DACs in respective devices (multibit in DAC2 vs Delta-sgma in Sangean). HDT-20 playback sounded more direct and upfront while DAC2 playback was laid back and more revealing.

Then I brought the CD which was played on that day, Bach Keyboard Concertos, by Andrei Gavrilov, Neville Marriner, ASMF, EMI (7640552). During playback, I didn't hear a much big difference between CD via DAC2 and what I heard the other day. Of course, I am recalling this from my memory and I think playbacks were very similar or at least closer in playback. 

I have been debating for a while whether to buy a digital streamer and then I came across this interesting comparison of HD radio playback versus digital streamers. "HD stations don't suffer from audio compression like streaming and satellite radio can. Also noted the impressive sound difference; HD Radio stations had fuller sound with better bass."

Appreciate if you please share your experience of comparing CD sound quality against digital streamers of the same material. Also any thought on HD playback versus digital streamers?

 

pwerahera
secretguy
1,730 posts
 

I only have HD in my car, although my car system is pretty good. Sounds great to me.

v-fi
110 posts
 

I would listen to music played out of a tin can with a string connected to it, if it was music I loved and that was the only way to hear it. This is why I use Spotify and Bandcamp even though they aren't the best quality.

But when given more choices I would always choose the best sounding option. To me HD Radio sounds worlds better than SeriusXM which is barely listenable. But it isn't as good as CD or lossless streaming like Tidal or Qobuz. 

Basically enjoy what you have that plays music you like and sounds good enough to you.

yyzsantabarbara
4,917 posts
 

HD radio is awful. I compared it to the FM signal from KCRW.com and the over the air HD was unlistenable to me. The FM is amazing. I had the great little Sony HD radio for HD and FM. The FM was bester on that.

On my Magnum Dynalab MD108T FM tuner vs the Sony HD there was no competition.

mahler123
3,378 posts
 

Is HD Radio synonymous with Internet Radio?  I had never heard the term prior to reading this thread.  My Googling suggests that it is just a rebranding of Internet Radio which I have been listening to for years.

  Most Internet Radio stations broadcast at relatively low bit rate.  Some, such as Radio Venice (128 bps) still manage to sound pretty good, so bit rate isn’t the whole story, apparently.  However, our Chicago Classical station, WFMT, streams at 320 bps and sounds very close to CD.  It blows the OTA feed away, and I sold off my Magnum Dynalab tuner years ago since that and the other Internet stations such as Venice are what I listen to.

carlsbad2's avatar
carlsbad2
1,702 posts
 

When I first started streaming I did A/B testing with CDs and found streaming sounded better.  That is when I upgraded to a CD transport to feed my standalone DAC and now no difference.  I had friends do blind tests and we found no difference.  Now I almost never listen to a CD.

as others have said.  HD radio isn't really HD compared to lossless.

Jerry

More to discover