which is a better speaker

Choose better speakers. Crabby?

Guy complains about free advice! Next time I think he should tell us what he wants to hear in the OP to prevent the respondents from wasting their time. 

Guy complains about free advice!

Reminds me of the expression: "If everybody says your drunk. You better sit down". Pretty much all of us tried to lead the OP in the right direction but our advice was not appreciated. 

OP,

Sorry but you have to invest some effort if you want useful feedback. What is your experience level, what kind of sound are you looking for? What kind of room? 
 

You got a lot of thoughtful advice given the seconds you put into a one line question.

@mahgister ,

I agree with your room comments to a point. Depending on the size of the room and how far you sit away makes a difference. For instance if you have a 15x20 room and put the speakers on the short wall and sit 7-8ft away room treatments don’t matter all that much unless you play at loud levels