Why are my woofers pumping?

Dear @o_holter : """   compliance is similar to the Atlas so the test may not tell much........ """"

well, you have a " problem " that till today you don't know exactly the reason or reasons for it. You assumed that cartridge/tonearm resonance is the culprit but you really don't know because you just don't want to make tests as listen the same system with different cartridges ( Clavis DC. ) or with different tonearm that you can borrow from somewhere or some one.

Clavis has same compliance: so what? from where came that can't tell you nalmost nothing?

makes no sense that kind of answers from you because you need to find out ( or maybe not. ) what's happening making different kind of tests and if you don't want to do it then is better to just forgeret about as invictus005 said and try to enjoy MUSIC.

R.

one thing to try

play a record Try to move your tonearm on the record sideways with a light feather

if the tone arm doesn’t move sideways
chances are the bearing in the tone arm is rigid causing It to not move correctly

if the bearing is locked up
all the up down motion of the cartridge to the record is occurring via the cantilever not the arm bearing

the cantilever going up and down produces woofer pumping



Best wishes

Audiotomb - I already tried the feather test, and found no problem. I also contacted SME who said, basically, if you don’t notice a problem with the V, it should be fine.

Raul sensibly suggested (going the resonance path, along with invictus005 and others) - test with the Clavis DC ca 2007 model that I have on my loft (not much used, since I soon changed to a Titan).
So I’ve done it. Interesting to hear the sound of the Clavis - from back then. Quite decent.

Pumping? I am sure you’re all dying to hear the result!

First impression: less pumping, maybe only normal woofer energy.
Testing the 2016 remaster of New gold dream. And then, with even more clear result, Pink Floyd Meddle.
There is a lot of woofer energy, yes. But less, or very little, of the visual-only pumping. So the "subsonic overwork" of the woofers seems far less. Or mainly absent.

This seems to confirm the resonance problem view. There are some doubts however. First, there is the possibility that some woofer pumping is actually not a big problem - just look away from it. As was suggested early in this thread. I mean, the Atlas sounds better than the Clavis, reaching further down, more explosive dynamics, wider soundscape. After ten minutes listening to the Clavis, I want my Atlas back. Also I've noted that LPs with pumping often sound good.

 Second, I am not sure of the compliance of the Clavis - is it 12 or maybe ca 20 (due to failure to translate the Japanese 100hz rating). It weighs 2.1 g less than the Atlas, though. According to the vinylengine calculator, even a compliance of 20 is thereby enough to get me into "green" territory. This seems in line with my results. I cannot test with the HFN record since it is on loan to a friend.

Dear @o_holter : Nice result you experienced with the Clavis ( that ovbiously is not even a " small " challenge for the great Atlas. ).

""" So the "subsonic overwork" of the woofers seems far less. Or mainly absent. """

Either the Clavis/Atlas compliance and weigth puts the resonance frequency in the " green " territory as you said. So, seems no trouble for that and very specific tonearm/cartridge resonance frequency issue.

I imagine that you already tested both cartridges using the SME V in static and balanced way about the VTF set up.

Your Atlas has over 1,500 hours of use that are not way higher but not way low number.
Trhough those 1,500 hours stylus tip and cartridge suspension are the ones that could starts to work outside manufacturer specs and I’m not saying that’s your case but only thinking " fully loaded voice ".

Who can tell you if any problem down there? not a single re-tipper but the manufacturer it self. maybe time to talk with J.Carr for he can take a look to your beloved Atlas.
In the mid time you can re-tip your Clavis with a re-tipper using boron cantilever and you will be surprised the Clavis improvements.

Anyway, I think you need to try JC directly.

R.

Invictus005 wrote: " This has to be the most ridiculous thread on Audiogon at the moment. Everything and all of it. OP, I told you it’s a problem YOU can’t solve. Just enjoy the music. Some of these things are just part of vinyl. Many comments here have crossed the line of insanity. Seems like some people want to end up in a mental hospital?"
Let me posit this in a positive way. "Sound is good. Relax. With a good cart you get some vinyl pumping. Look away". Ok? If so, I agree. Fits my evidence, mostly.

But the thread, even if ignorant or repetetive, is not ridiculous. A large list of potential problems, regarding low rumble and woofer pumping, has been listed and described. Even if low cart-arm resonance is the main culprit in my case, the suggestions are interesting on their own, for anyone investigating low frequency vinyl problems in resolving systems.