Why Do Schumann Resonators Work?

You attack people here, I attack the erroneous content in your posts. You have already shown everyone else you have lost the argument. Too late. Ship has sailed. People who attack people in forums and not their post content ...do so because they can't.

The sub based antenna "could" transmit, but the amount of RF power that could be generated would be low. The long length of the ground based system and the high transmit powers allows more RF power to be generated. The ELF generator for sub communications (whose antenna are not all full wavelength and many are less) has a transmission power of millions of watts. Did you learn anything in that radio room?


Why do Schumann generators have no range? ... Hmmmmm

I know enough to know when you’re lying. When ever you open your mouth.

you said,

“The sub based antenna "could" transmit, but the amount of RF power that could be generated would be low.”

No shirt, Sherlock. That’s why the system was designed to be a one-way system. The sub has no transmitter. There is no need for two way communication. You’ve been flapping your gums instead of paying attention.

It is perfectly capable of transmitting which you just admitted. You just admitted a few hundred feet long antenna can transmit low frequencies .... Awesome you are finally learning !!!

LOL 😂 You’re putting words in my mouth. I said no such thing, in fact I’ve been saying the opposite. Put on your listening ears. The sub is not (rpt not) capable of transmitting at ELF frequency. Even if it had a transmitter, which it doesn’t. It would require a *very large* antenna at ELF frequency. And a lot (rpt lot) of transmit power. Not only that but the land-based system is not (rpt not) equipped with a RECEIVER. It only has a TRANSMITTER. Hel-loo! Earth to audiozenology! Come in! 👨‍🚀The way the ELF system actually works is much more logical than you’re wild imagination. The submerged sub RECEIVES the ELF message, Then it nearly surfaces to have two-way communications on VLF frequency. 3-30 kHz. But even the sub’s VLF antenna is very long. Hel-loo! Do the math!

So, to have only one-way communication on ELF frequency of 76 Hz a huge antenna and enormous transmit power plus a super-sensitive receiver on the sub is required. 84 miles and 1 Million watts. That’s just for one-way communication. Follow? 

See, that wasn’t so difficult, was it? Of course this is all moot since the ELF system was dismantled so time ago in 2004.

Wiki quick study,

ELF radio waves are generated by lightning and natural disturbances in Earth’s magnetic field, so they are a subject of research by atmospheric scientists. Because of the difficulty of building antennas that can radiate such long waves, ELF frequencies have been used in only a very few man-made communication systems. ELF waves can penetrate seawater, which makes them useful in communication with submarines, and a few nations have built military ELF transmitters to transmit signals to their submerged submarines, consisting of huge grounded wire antennas (ground dipoles) 15 - 60 km long driven by transmitters producing megawatts of power. The US, Russia, India, and China are the only nations known to have constructed these ELF communication facilities.[6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13] The U.S. facilities were used between 1985 and 2004 but are now decommissioned.[9]

1+++ geoffkait, couldn't have said it better myself:)