Your Pick Between These Two...


Room acoustics/size, equipment and musical tastes, all relative, which would you chose?

Joseph Audio Perspectives or Magico A3's

I'll leave it open, as I know there will be a multitude of other offerings. All other suggestions are greatly welcomed as long as you feel they may compete with all the requirements and SQ of the two originals in question. Particularly, if they come in under priced!

Thanks
128x128navyachts
Is neither an option?

I don't like ports anymore, so no to Joseph Audio and I don't recommend low efficiency of Magico. (I wouldn't buy metal in any case).

I recommend selecting high efficiency speakers, to keep power needs minimized, to keep options to try tubes affordable.

If you know your power needs are going to be smaller, reducing amp cost, that gives you more money to spend on speakers, by far the most important choice.
Magico A3 by a fair margin as long as you have the power. If you want to go loud on limited power then Klipsch Cornwall III's 
MAGICO A3s are a great sounding speaker however this being said you need top flight amp, preamp and great copper cables.Great cables are Furutech or Purist copper.Enjoy whatever you get there is usually a wait of at least several months on MAGICO.
https://youtu.be/Ma7dvPyr5T0
Read more about these, I've never liked a speaker as much. Had a wilson, a focal, a bunch of other speakers (not top of the lines but still). These need little power, so natural/neutral sounding, will fill your room with amazing sound provided its not super huge (up to 40m2), they have very decent bass even they are single drivers!
navyachts

What amp do you have nobody knows yet, this should be the first criteria, before any suggestions are made.

As the Magico’s need an amp with guts (current) as they are 3ohms in most of the bass/upper bass and also 3ohms in the upper mids.
https://www.stereophile.com/images/archivesart/508Magfig1.jpg

Where the Perspectives are an easy load and don’t need a muscle amp.
https://www.stereophile.com/images/614Jopefig1.jpg

Not to say you need a lot of watts with the Magico’s at 87db a 100w will do, but it need to be a muscular amp that can do current into 2ohms to be comfortable.

The Perspectives how ever are an easy load, but are only 84db and would like an amp of 150w or more, but it can be a light weight mosfet, tube or even a Class-D, my preference in that order.

Cheers George