In re: rating something one number but saying it is another ("I'm rating it a 2 but really it is a 10"). I have no problem with that. As someone mentioned above, it provides leeway in people's different interpretations. I may feel something is a 9 but someone else may think It is a 10, but someone else yet may see it and rate it a 7. That's a big swing in ratings and, consequently, a big potential swing in value. To deal with this I think a better solution is a picture, giving your own interpretation. OTOH, I understand why some people find this annoying.