Recommendation - Complete Beethoven Sonatas

I would also lean towards Goode over Brendel just between the two. Is it possible to say that Brendel's playing is many times "too perfect" ?

You might also be able to piece together a set separately by Murray Perahia.

For other "historic" recordings you can probably piece together an almost complete set by Solomon or Richter.

Another nod for Goode. Although in ultimate terms I prefer Schnabel and Kempf, the fidelity is pretty low on those (1930's and mid-50s respectively) I admire Brendel a great deal, but his set(s) are pretty rigorous and intellectual-- not perhaps the only one(s) to have if you're having only one. Goode is excelllent all around, and is recorded wonderfully. You could live happily ever after.

And I'll offer yet another view in favor of Wilhelm Kempff. His recordings on DGG are in generally good sound, and his interpretations are always well thought.

I've not heard any of the performances by Goode. I'll have to explore his interpretations - thanks!

Another vote for Goode. I have both the Goode and the Kempff sets and prefer the Goode ever so slightly. Both pianists are exemplary.

Let me confuse the issue by recommending the Pollini along with the Brendel and the Goode.