Is Apogee in a class by itself among planars?


As a former owner of Apogee Stages, after listening to a number of popular planars, I still feel that Apogee produced an uncanny feeling of live music better than anything else IMHO all these years later. Although they weren't the most detailed, didn't have very well defined bass, and didn't have a very holistic soundstage, there was just something undefineable to me that sounded real (even when listening from the another room), along with unsurpassed vocals, that makes me say "There's something about Apogees." Am I hallucinating? If not, how was this achieved?
rgs92
Correction: As noted above, the Apogees (and Maggie IIIa's) are ribbons, and not planars. I think Audio Asylum, which I read alot, got me associating planars with ribbons because they title their forum the "Planar" forum, although ribbons and electrostats are discussed there too.
The Analysis Ribbons at CES sounded pretty awesome, and reminded of the best Apogee systems that I've heard.
See photo/desc. in Olsher's show report...
http://enjoythemusic.com/ces2006/olsher/
Cheers,
Spencer
"First of all, Apogee are not planars. They are ribbons."
"As noted above, the Apogees (and Maggie IIIa's) are ribbons, and not planars."

Would any one like to explain this distinction? A ribbon is a planar film driven in a particular way, afaik.

Kal
Kr4,

For an excellent primer on the differences between ribbons, planars, and electrostats, see the following link, beginning on page 10:

http://www.eminent-tech.com/Manuals/LFT-8Manual.PDF
Kr4...I have always found it easy to distinguish a ribbon from planar. A ribbon is very long and narrow...like 3/4 inch wide and 50 inches long. A planar speaker, like a Magnepanar will be more like 12 inches wide and 50 inches long. I would not take into account whether the drive is electrostatic or magnetic.