What speaker to buy to start over.

Not sure that any Vandy is really a rock speaker, but i never heard the 5 series (owned 2s and 3Asigs/2Ws). If the latter did not float your boat, then the 5s probably would not either. 17 x 25 is a good size room, $7k is a good size budget. If you are talking used, I would recommend Von Schwiekert VR 4 Srs, which seem to be available in that price range.

I personally don't think of electrostatic type speakers when I think of rock and roll. I'm not sure how much the Summits are, but if they fall in or around $9k, I would give Zuaudio's (a brand spanking new pairA of) Definition 1.5s a shot. They have an unbelievable moneyback guarantee, which you cannot beat with a stick: 60 days!! 101 db sensitivity. Jazz is my thing/female vocal/male and I can do reggae and good old fashion rock like in my Woodstock days. Speakers play with phenominal resolution at the lowest volumes and will drop your pictures on the floor at ear bleed level with only 100 watts. Would you believe they can handle 500 watts! There are oodles in the archives on the Definitions.

Silverline Sinfonia . No affiliation with the seller.

Looked through the current list and, in your range, I would second the Dunlavy SCV (CT) and also suggest the Genesis 2.5's (NY) or the Infinity IRS Betas (LA). Unfortunately, shipping is restrictive for these heavyweights. There is a pair of Krell Resolutions but I don't know enough about them to recommend.

If your planning on new, look at VMPS and Reimer. The latter can be driven by smaller amps.

Staring all over again...huh? You have pre-selected Martin Logan Summits? Didn't you have Martin Logans before? I wouldn't call that a fresh start.

I second Bob's comment...at least give some active speakers an audition. You might be surprised by what you discover....exceptional driver integration, ultra low IMD distortion and better dynamics than you will find in any electrostat.