After tinkering with the placement of the phonostage and the gain settings, I am suspecting the preamp is the culprit.
Am I wrong in feeling funny about 3 o'clock on the volume to get a rockin' experience? Seems like the high dial position is pushing the ability of the preamp too far. One would think that my pre and power amp should be a good match though. They are both from the same era, same company, and same price point.
as it is, the sound is excellent, I am just complaint about the noise floor, which could be reduced.