I just went through this process of replacing a CD player. I listened to the following:
Yamaha CD-S2100
Marantz SA8005
Marantz CD 6006
Atoll CD 200SE
Simaudio Neo 260D
I could have lived with any of the above but in the end it was a run off between the Atoll and the Simaudio. I was able to A/B them on my system which was a bit of a pain as they have slightly different live level output levels which required adjusting volume for fairness.
In the end the Simaudio won out. I liked the horn sound better and the bass was a little tauter (although I felt the Atoll went deeper). The build was better for the Simaudio in particular the CD tray was far more robust. The clinchers were the 10 year warranty for the Simaudio (2 years on the tray) along with their trade up program (up to 100% in the first year).
Yamaha CD-S2100
Marantz SA8005
Marantz CD 6006
Atoll CD 200SE
Simaudio Neo 260D
I could have lived with any of the above but in the end it was a run off between the Atoll and the Simaudio. I was able to A/B them on my system which was a bit of a pain as they have slightly different live level output levels which required adjusting volume for fairness.
In the end the Simaudio won out. I liked the horn sound better and the bass was a little tauter (although I felt the Atoll went deeper). The build was better for the Simaudio in particular the CD tray was far more robust. The clinchers were the 10 year warranty for the Simaudio (2 years on the tray) along with their trade up program (up to 100% in the first year).