You don't mention a budget, Josh. And just to clarify; you want something that will rip and store CDs, or Play downloads, with no DAC?
I myself use a Bluesound Vault 2. It has a DAC which I bypass through it's digital outs and use my own DACs, and it has a 2 TB HD which would be really ample for your collection. It will play high res files and can recognize other sources such as your PC. It cost $1100 and of course you would feel as if you were wasting some of those dollars on the unwanted DAC
I myself use a Bluesound Vault 2. It has a DAC which I bypass through it's digital outs and use my own DACs, and it has a 2 TB HD which would be really ample for your collection. It will play high res files and can recognize other sources such as your PC. It cost $1100 and of course you would feel as if you were wasting some of those dollars on the unwanted DAC