Thanks to all of you so far with your supportive comments... I think that music-reproduction quality is definitely in the ears of the beholder. No one has said positive things about Sophia's reliability, so I'll keep steering clear of their products. I have tried the Gold Lion's and JJ's and prefer the sound of the Sophia's over those, however will try the Psvanes...
Psvane 300-B Tubes ? ? ?
Does anyone out there have any experience with Psvane 300-B MKII or their WE300-B Replica tubes ?
I found the best sound from initially the Sophia Princess mesh-plate 300-B's, then their Royal Princess 300-B's however I'm definitely NOT happy with their reliability, especially the Royal Princess !
I had a mesh-plate from new have a glowing spot on the mesh-plate, and they told me it was from sitting on the shelf for over a year ! REALLY ! ? ! ? And I had two Royal Princess tubes go out with less than 600-hours on them, unfortunately well-past 1-yr. warranty. Left a bad taste... I'm NOT going back...
I've tried EH gold-grid 300-B's, Gold-Lion's, JJ's... All sound somewhat different but the Sophias sounded the best, however in my experience, reliability is questionable... Thanks... John
I found the best sound from initially the Sophia Princess mesh-plate 300-B's, then their Royal Princess 300-B's however I'm definitely NOT happy with their reliability, especially the Royal Princess !
I had a mesh-plate from new have a glowing spot on the mesh-plate, and they told me it was from sitting on the shelf for over a year ! REALLY ! ? ! ? And I had two Royal Princess tubes go out with less than 600-hours on them, unfortunately well-past 1-yr. warranty. Left a bad taste... I'm NOT going back...
I've tried EH gold-grid 300-B's, Gold-Lion's, JJ's... All sound somewhat different but the Sophias sounded the best, however in my experience, reliability is questionable... Thanks... John
- ...
- 37 posts total
One thing I learned in development of the NiWatt amplifier is that you can’t take anyone’s word for it (I actually knew that). I’m poking the bear here, but my point is that like any architecture, 300B amplifiers are wildly different and one person’s assessment of a tube plugged into their amplifier is very likely to be different from how that person would respond if he plugged those tubes into your amplifier. A large majority of 300B amplifiers (when driving appropriate speakers) have a big, fat upper bass and lower midrange. This has been the "knock" on 300B amplifiers, but in fact, the original 300B tube design is very flat in its frequency response. Most of a 300B amplifier’s "sound" comes from the power supply and the driver circuit implementation. Needless to say, these design attributes differ greatly in different designs. With that disclaimer, if you want a good, reliable inexpensive 300B, get a JJ. If you’re cork sniffing (guilty as charged), pick up a set of Emmission Labs from Tubes USA (no affiliation, but he’s great guy): http://www.tubesusa.com/ Cheers, Thom @ Galibier Design |
Here here ! Most 300-B tubes I have tried sound good. The subtle differences are in the Mfg and elements used I believe. As for the amps, yes... the PSU's and other components (ie... transformers) help make up or color the sound. I have a BorderPatrol S20 dual-mono parallel 300-B SET amp and the response is very linear. I prefer the sound of the Sophia Royal Princess tubes and if it weren't for my negative experiences with reliability would still have them. That's why I am looking for a great replacement. |
Liquidsound, I heard a pair of the Sophia Royal Princess in my amplifier for several weeks courtesy of a generous loan from a fellow audiogon member. It was a very good sounding tube but I felt that the Takatsuki was overall better sounding. As Thom mentioned above the Emission Labs (EML) is worth serious consideration and similar price range of the Sophia RP. I don’t know if Thom uses the standard EML 300b or the XLS version (that I have). As acknowledged certain tubes will sound better/worse depending on the particular amplifier in use. Thom I’ve read comments by Lynn Olsen regarding your Niwatt 300b SET amplifier and he is highly impressed. Charles |
- 37 posts total