Acman, liked the last Tequilla 'shot' too.
Make me think of another one...its not jazz, but its fine...
https://youtu.be/Uedw8ErZ3akFrogman, well written post.
Still, one sentence made me want to add the thought....
It is when you mentioned the '
coziness of consonance and easily followed and understood musical lines and harmonies' and the way the Coltrane played before the death.
Another sax player came to my mind, Ike Quebec and his last album, recorded in the almost same sad sitauation as Coltrane's.
Of course, they played 'different' style of music, but Quebec chose to record 'Soul Samba', which to uninformed listener may sound exactly the way you describe time that was absent when Coltrane played.
And, yet, I have a same feeling about it, like you have with Coltrane's last work.
Almost reluctance to listen it, aldo is one of my favorite albums, becuse of such profound emotions that are 'packed' in and effect they have on me.
What I wanted to say is that sometimes the form can be 'simple' like drinking cup of tea, but that still can be a zen experience.
Sometimes I like to think (perhaps I am wrong) that many records and music transcends its original form, because of emotion, artistry or just inspiration of that moment and it allows us to feel the hidden depths of 'beauty and soul'
It is very seductive feeling and I am very aware of it, looking at it from 'bigger picture' of what else music may represent, but also I think it is the basic root behind of all your and Orpheus 'discussion'