maybe you are partly right IMO. Yes myth can sometimes influence judgement, but in many cases, time tells the truth.
All the people who have listened and compared old EMT, Thorens, Garrad, etc to some of the best tables of these days can’t be only influenced by myth when they prefer old timers. Also old TT have to be very carefully restored for being competitive.
Imagine that if old people with all their knoledge and experience could be « restored « as well... 🤪