Are HT speakers best for primary audio listening or not?


Hello sports fans!

Regarding my picks for music listening, I’ve got a short list of loudspeakers which seems to evolve and diminish and then grow again. Although it sits with five or less models on it usually.

The one I feel is at the top of the list is as yet, an unknown entity. I ain’t heared it yet. If and when I do, it likely isn’t gonna be heard with the electronics I would use to support it. So, it will be as with so many at best ‘guess speculation’ if purchased.

Here’s the Dilly Dilly….

In one quite well written account by a popular long time reviewer, he states among other sterling attributes, this would make for an excellent hi end home theater loud speaker.

QUESTION:

What is the argument for or against HT speakers as primary 2 ch audio listening speakers.

Is there a decided separation in speaker land lately between HT speakers and stereo or primary music only speakers??

I’ve always sought music first speakers even if HT would or could be an added task for the main speakers later on, and simply accepted the results.

Not entirely positive this go ‘round, but most likely, whatever music first speaker I choose will NOT see any HT duty.

Thanks for your related experience.

blindjim


@blindjim-- I think you have to be more specific about the speaker, amplifier(s) and your room. For some years, I ran a large home theatre, using some big Snells in a D’Appolito configuration, with multiple basic amps from ARC. At the time, I was using Crosby Quads as my main two channel speaker, and did not want to subject them to the pounding that a HT system can impose at high dbs.
The size of the room and screen may also involve a spread between the L+R that aren’t conducive to stereo imaging-- (unless you are confining your music listening to 5.1 type mixes).
There’s also the complication of systems- I know some folks can get double duty from a HT and stereo system, but I didn’t want a bunch of additional electronics connected to what amounted to a simple, vinyl-only stereo, so I kept the systems entirely separate (even though both, over the years, as they evolved, were in the same room). This requires some intelligent use of the space, and room treatment, since the projection screen, unless a motorized drop down (which I used in an earlier HT system) is a highly reflective surface for acoustic purposes.
Generally, I would think some modern speakers would be well suited for HT use, such a larger horns, or bigger dynamic speakers.
There’s also the matter of how the subwoofers are crossed over for theatre v. music. I suppose if they are run through a processor that allows you to change the crossover point for different types of listening that solves one problem, but potentially adds another- I wouldn’t want to run my stereo through a pre-pro meant for home theatre. I gather that’s why there is a by-pass on many set-ups, but I avoided those complications by keeping the systems separate.
Hi Jim,

Just in general, kind of depends on how neutral a speaker you like for music, which I need to define for this conversation:

Neutral: Plays many types of music equally well.

Those types of speakers do really well with HT. However, if you like 80s R&R a lot, and buy speakers based on playing that loud the same speakers are probably not going to do quite as well in HT.

However, lets put this into perspective. It doesn't all have to be perfect. You won't live longer or less if you buy speakers better for Jazz than HT. :)

Best,


E