Yes if Royj was at the session then he can use that session as a barometer.
The reality is we have no idea of what a John Coltrane performance was actually sounding like unless we were there.
Many mastering engineers can alter tonal balance, add echo and reverb and change the actual taped performance to make a recording sound good as a finished product.
Not all recording and mastering engineers belive in a more hands off approach.
Again if that particular performance moved Royj great for Royj that doesn't mean another listener will find that same sound to be as good.
We set up a Naim system with ATC SCM 40 on a Naim NAC 272, 250dr, XPS system with Isotek power conditioning, all high performance cabling, and the sound was very realistic, with an excellent sense of image width depth, clarity and dynamics. The top end was very clear.
We played Beatles a Hard Days Night and it sounded like a great 60's recording, with a tad bit of brittleness on top, went to Black Sabath and it was spooky. Played some more modern recordings and the sound was more refined.
The point is the Beatles recording sounded like a recording from its time, the slight hardness was in the recording. and the system accurately conveyed that, if you don't like reality a system such as this one might not be to your tastes, YMMV
Dave and Troy
Audio Doctor NJ
The reality is we have no idea of what a John Coltrane performance was actually sounding like unless we were there.
Many mastering engineers can alter tonal balance, add echo and reverb and change the actual taped performance to make a recording sound good as a finished product.
Not all recording and mastering engineers belive in a more hands off approach.
Again if that particular performance moved Royj great for Royj that doesn't mean another listener will find that same sound to be as good.
We set up a Naim system with ATC SCM 40 on a Naim NAC 272, 250dr, XPS system with Isotek power conditioning, all high performance cabling, and the sound was very realistic, with an excellent sense of image width depth, clarity and dynamics. The top end was very clear.
We played Beatles a Hard Days Night and it sounded like a great 60's recording, with a tad bit of brittleness on top, went to Black Sabath and it was spooky. Played some more modern recordings and the sound was more refined.
The point is the Beatles recording sounded like a recording from its time, the slight hardness was in the recording. and the system accurately conveyed that, if you don't like reality a system such as this one might not be to your tastes, YMMV
Dave and Troy
Audio Doctor NJ