prof - well, at least we agree on the Thiels. I'm a twenty-five plus year user of same, and their coherence and attention to diffraction elimination do pay imaging dividends, for sure.
I also agree that the Thiels, in a decent acoustic environment successfully admit a bit of "roundness" to the sound .... call it "body" if you will. But I stand by my guns in saying you simply don't hear much roundness when listening to live music from a normal venue seating position, nor can you pinpoint directionality.that precisely. In an orchestral recording you can generally sense the cellos and bass on the right, and the first violins on the left, but that is about it. Brassy horns will have a semblance of directionality as will percussion, but not pinpoint definition. As I said before, I can create it in a dedicated listening room ... it is a matter of placement and sound treatment, one way or the other, but unless you prefer sitting in the conductors chair, or on the edge of the stage, the "hologram" effect we audiophiles strive for is just not realistic. But more importantly, IMO it is far less important than realistic dynamics and tonal accuracy in conveying the musical import.
I also agree that the Thiels, in a decent acoustic environment successfully admit a bit of "roundness" to the sound .... call it "body" if you will. But I stand by my guns in saying you simply don't hear much roundness when listening to live music from a normal venue seating position, nor can you pinpoint directionality.that precisely. In an orchestral recording you can generally sense the cellos and bass on the right, and the first violins on the left, but that is about it. Brassy horns will have a semblance of directionality as will percussion, but not pinpoint definition. As I said before, I can create it in a dedicated listening room ... it is a matter of placement and sound treatment, one way or the other, but unless you prefer sitting in the conductors chair, or on the edge of the stage, the "hologram" effect we audiophiles strive for is just not realistic. But more importantly, IMO it is far less important than realistic dynamics and tonal accuracy in conveying the musical import.