Vinyl***What If***

Try you can get many recordings on CD that you can’t get on vinyl which at least on acoustic ,aka jazz and classical music, is always better .
Not to mention if you haven’t gone to at least a few hundred live music concerts you don’t really know what music really sounds like anyway .
A rock concert is not live music .

What Michael says is that each time you compare two sources in one system one is sure to lose. Better always win, no comparisons, as junk as something might be. Better than nothing, anyway.

@schubert :

"A rock concert is not live music"

I just love statements like that. I've been to symphonies, indoors and out, I've been to opera (in Italy), I've been to chamber music series in tiny rooms in Charleston, SC, I've been to live jazz performances, I've been to live blues shows in dives and sketchy haunts in Clarksdale Mississippi and I've been to a few rock concerts. Take my word for it, they are live. Sure, you can go to a bad one but that's true with all of the above. And yes you can see one in a stadium which to me is pointless. But a good rock show in a small to medium venue is as good or better, to me, as any of the above.

Maybe you haven't been to a good show?

I think you are wrong , very wrong but too big a topic for right here and now .

Schubert probably means that rock music is not quite real music. It is certainly not purist unamplified acoustic music.
Never attended but Pink Floyd concerts look very impressive on screen.