Thanks to everyone for the comments. Lots of differing opinions here. I’m leaning towards second hand because I wanted a DD (I want a simple button to change speeds) and the Pioneer PLX 1000 seems to be the only decent new one that would fit within my budget.
In on the other hand, there are an assortment of Luxmans, Pioneers, Yamahas, Kenwoods, listed in CL at the moment. Most are under $750. I’ve used CL with success before and was able to audition before purchasing. I also see that there are eBay sellers who specialize in restoring vintage TTs. I am willing to expand my budget but I prefer to purchase something that is ready to use out of the box.
I have heard TTs at local dealers but most new units are way beyond $1000 or even $3000.