I think I am posting too much lately. Somebody stop me.
: )
: )
Jazz for aficionados
frogman In the Adair and Sinatra versions of "Fly Me to the Moon" for me the thing that "locks in " the song is their impeccable sense of swing. That ,along with the tempo makes their versions right for the listener. I give credit to Adair's trio members for locking in the tempo solidly. Krall tries to impart her own different sense of swing in the lyrics on her number which fails , especially in the middle and end of the song. I always feel it's difficult for a singer to cover a song for which another ( Sinatra in this case) has done what most consider a definitive version and her attempt to make it her own falls short. |
Keep posting mary_jo. Re Krall: Not a fan. I find her deliveries bland and pretty much the opposite of what I consider “nailing” a tune. Sorry, it was just a gratuitous dig. No point in getting on the Krall bashing bandwagon. Much more productive to discuss Sinatra who was undoubtedly a great singer. So is fillet a great cut of beef; but, give me sirloin any day. I agree with Schubert. For me, there was a quality in his singing (not nearly as much in a young Sinatra) that makes me feel like he felt he was doing the audience a favor by singing. The simple joy of singing of someone like Bennett is not there for me. Just me. https://youtu.be/kP1F7_G4Adc |