New Magnepan 1.7


I posted a response to this thread but it (the thread) remained buried in the thread listings – I thought it would be advanced to the “current queue.”

Anyway, since I would like to hear your opinions on the subject, I am restating my post to the original thread as a new thread (I apologize for the redundancy):

I just listened to the new 1.7s at the local dealer, who forewarned me that they sounded terrible due to not being broken in. Indeed, they sounded very thin, tizzy and totally lacking any dynamics in the mid-bass or bass frequencies. The dealer told me that this was to be expected and that he fully expects them to sound great once properly broken in.

When the 1.7s arrived, the dealer compared them to his 1.6s that were fully broken in and which he said totally blew away the new 1.7s (I did not get to hear this comparison since he recently sold his 1.6 demo pair). Through the 1.7s I felt that various well-recorded acoustic music did sound very promising, with respect to the resolution in the upper frequencies already sounding detailed and resolved, but when more dynamic material was played (rock, electronic, large orchestral passages, bass & drum) they sounded unacceptably thin and lacking bass of any substance whatsoever.

I have no real experience with Magies. Is this long (and necessary) break in time to be expected, and if so, how much do “new Magies” improve with break in? I have to wonder about all the glowing reviews…for their reviews, do the reviewers receive “pre-conditioned” (fully broken in) speakers?

I plan to revisit the dealer in about four weeks to reevaluate the new 1.7s.

I would appreciate other opinions (regarding the 1.7s)

Thanks.

Ben
2chnlben
If you wait 4 weeks to go back,they will probably be gone!!Lots of folks want these speakers and will buy them without being "broke in".Just a thought.
Thanks Tpreaves.

They won't sell these since they are the floor demos and they'll want to have them on hand for potential buyers. I'm just curious about the break in time for Magies. I’d like to hear from experienced Magnepan owners about the immediate sound of their new speakers compared to after the full break in period (and what that timeline may be)…what to expect, etc.

Appreciated…
Post removed 
Thanks Elizabeth.

I love the dynamic range of driver-based boxed systems, but I have a passion for midrange clarity and sweet highs. For me, there has always been a tradeoff and I have until recently been satisfied with the compromise I experience with dynamic box speakers.

I relish being able to really crank the volume and feel the impact when the rocking mood strikes me and since I grew up in the seventies, that mood strikes often. What moves me even more though is the sweet sound of acoustic music and female vocals, whether it be folk, singer/songwriter, jazz, classical, blues or new age, I truly love the sound of live acoustic music. Given this, think I’m ready to give up the thundering dynamics for the sweet midrange and highs of a planner speaker. But, for me, this necessarily means compromising since my rock, funk and huge orchestral passages simply will not sound as grand and dynamic.

The 1.7s have certainly caught my attention so I am very interested in the opinions of magie owners in general and of course from those experienced with the 1.7s. I would like to hear about incorporating subs with the magies as well and how the combination sounds with big sweeping symphonic and orchestral passages and on loud seventies rock music (e.g.: Zep, Purple, Sabbath, War, etc…). I know magies can sound very special, but my brief experience with the (new) 1.7s was a real let down.

Thanks