uberwaltz
Well, since I, like many here, actually have access to both "lifestyles" - I have a convenient digital streaming set up and a vinyl set up - I already know the result of the experiment. I am getting much more pleasure out of my vinyl these days than my digital.
As physical artifacts, few of my DVDs or Blu-Rays ever gave much satisfaction. Like CDs they were mostly carriers for the content and that was it. So long as CDs and DVDs/Blu-Rays were carriers for the best quality content, they were necessary.
But as soon as full CD-quality ripping/streaming became available, the rational for the physical copies mostly disappeared for me. Similarly, the quality of streaming movies has become really excellent and offers "the world of movies at my fingertips" just as I was trying to create at home. So I don't need those physical copies so much anymore.
Vinyl is a physical object that I enjoy holding and owning. It also means I get to use a turntable, and I LOVE nice turntable - my turntable is a pleasing combination of aesthetically and conceptually satisfying.It's just cool to look at and use. Then there is the fact that vinyl just sounds different, and often to me preferable, to digital.
So for my vinyl offers something that CDs and DVDs/Blu-Rays and digital streaming don't offer. They are features I actually enjoy and MISS from those formats, so I don't really pine for a scenario in which I only use streaming.