What are YOUR priorities in a speaker ...?Hi Prof,
In my case I agree wholeheartedly that tonality and timbre are priority number one when it comes to selecting a speaker. What can be confounding, though, is that perceived tonality and timbre are dependent on a composite of many factors. And consequently I put it a little differently in the following thread, which addressed a similar question some years ago:
https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/which-attributes-do-you-value-most
The OP in that thread, member Bryoncunningham, raised the following question:
Here is a list of attributes commonly valued by audiophiles, in no particular order:
1. Resolution
2. Soundstaging
3. PRaT
4. Dynamics
5. Tonal balance
6. Harmonic content
7. Accuracy
8. Coherence
9. Frequency extension
10. Scale
The list could go on and on, but you get the idea. I’m interested to hear which attributes people prioritize above others....
My answer in that thread:
1)Harmonic accuracy.
Which in turn encompasses or is affected by many of the factors that have been mentioned (tonal balance, harmonic content, accuracy, clarity, resolution, coherence, lifting of veils, freedom from distortion, etc.). To me "harmonic accuracy" is the most significant determinant of how "real" the instruments sound. I realize that by lumping its contributing factors together I am begging the question :-)
2)Clean transient response.
3)Dynamic range.
4)Frequency extension.
5)Image scale.
Best regards,
-- Al